News and Document archive source
copyrighted material disclaimer at bottom of page

NewsMinewar-on-terrorunited-states — Viewing Item


Warcollege professor report compares waronterror to hitler { January 12 2004 }

Original Source Link: (May no longer be active)
   http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A8435-2004Jan11.html

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A8435-2004Jan11.html

Study Published by Army Criticizes War on Terror's Scope

By Thomas E. Ricks
Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, January 12, 2004; Page A12

A scathing new report published by the Army War College broadly criticizes the Bush administration's handling of the war on terrorism, accusing it of taking a detour into an "unnecessary" war in Iraq and pursuing an "unrealistic" quest against terrorism that may lead to U.S. wars with states that pose no serious threat.

The report, by Jeffrey Record, a visiting professor at the Air War College at Maxwell Air Force Base in Alabama, warns that as a result of those mistakes, the Army is "near the breaking point."

It recommends, among other things, scaling back the scope of the "global war on terrorism" and instead focusing on the narrower threat posed by the al Qaeda terrorist network.

"[T]he global war on terrorism as currently defined and waged is dangerously indiscriminate and ambitious, and accordingly . . . its parameters should be readjusted," Record writes. Currently, he adds, the anti-terrorism campaign "is strategically unfocused, promises more than it can deliver, and threatens to dissipate U.S. military resources in an endless and hopeless search for absolute security."

Record, a veteran defense specialist and author of six books on military strategy and related issues, was an aide to then-Sen. Sam Nunn when the Georgia Democrat was chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee.

In discussing his political background, Record also noted that in 1999 while on the staff of the Air War College, he published work critical of the Clinton administration.

His essay, published by the Army War College's Strategic Studies Institute, carries the standard disclaimer that its views are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of the Army, the Pentagon or the U.S. government.

But retired Army Col. Douglas C. Lovelace Jr., director of the Strategic Studies Institute, whose Web site carries Record's 56-page monograph, hardly distanced himself from it. "I think that the substance that Jeff brings out in the article really, really needs to be considered," he said.

Publication of the essay was approved by the Army War College's commandant, Maj. Gen. David H. Huntoon Jr., Lovelace said. He said he and Huntoon expected the study to be controversial, but added, "He considers it to be under the umbrella of academic freedom."

Larry DiRita, the top Pentagon spokesman, said he had not read the Record study. He added: "If the conclusion is that we need to be scaling back in the global war on terrorism, it's not likely to be on my reading list anytime soon."

Many of Record's arguments, such as the contention that Saddam Hussein's Iraq was deterred and did not present a threat, have been made by critics of the administration. Iraq, he concludes, "was a war-of-choice distraction from the war of necessity against al Qaeda." But it is unusual to have such views published by the War College, the Army's premier academic institution.

In addition, the essay goes further than many critics in examining the Bush administration's handling of the war on terrorism.

Record's core criticism is that the administration is biting off more than it can chew. He likens the scale of U.S. ambitions in the war on terrorism to Adolf Hitler's overreach in World War II. "A cardinal rule of strategy is to keep your enemies to a manageable number," he writes. "The Germans were defeated in two world wars . . . because their strategic ends outran their available means."

He also scoffs at the administration's policy, laid out by Bush in a November speech, of seeking to transform and democratize the Middle East. "The potential policy payoff of a democratic and prosperous Middle East, if there is one, almost certainly lies in the very distant future," he writes. "The basis on which this democratic domino theory rests has never been explicated."

He also casts doubt on whether the U.S. government will maintain its commitment to the war. "The political, fiscal, and military sustainability of the GWOT [global war on terrorism] remains to be seen," he states.

The essay concludes with several recommendations. Some are fairly noncontroversial, such as increasing the size of the Army and Marine Corps, a position that appears to be gathering support in Congress. But he also says the United States should scale back its ambitions in Iraq, and be prepared to settle for a "friendly autocracy" there rather than a genuine democracy.

To read the full report, go to washingtonpost.com/nation



2004 The Washington Post Company



anti-muslim
dictatorships
dissent
doctrine
foreigners
military-rapes
missile-defense
nukes
p2og
peculiar-activity
pentagon-secret-units
private-army
rumsfeld-memo-leak
soldier-suicides
southkorea-protests-US-2002
space-and-tech-weapons
tactics
targeted-killing
treaties
10 percent of mexicans work in america { May 21 2006 }
Agency initiates steps for selective draft { March 13 2004 }
Army officers and troops nabbed in drug sting
Army shows first uniform redesign since 1981
Army_new_uniform [jpg]
Bush asking for 401b defense budget exluding iraq afghanistan
Bush closes military bases across country { March 20 2005 }
Bush considers moving cia ops to pentagon
Bush puts asian organizations on terror list
Bush seeks big jump in defense spending
Bush state of union
Bush withdraws 70 thousand troops from overseas { August 15 2004 }
Caughts biowpeaons labs
Christian cowboy { October 23 2002 }
Clinton billions foil terrorism { September 10 2000 }
Closes peace keeping institute { May 8 2003 }
Dems want draft { January 7 2003 }
General says its fun to shoot some people
Guns flow easily into mexico from united states { January 8 2006 }
Land mind ban moral { October 21 2002 }
Marines outraged under brit command { March 16 2003 }
Military has growing drinking problem
Missile launchers dc
No absolute proof ap
Pentagon finance manager rabbi resigns { March 10 2004 }
Pentagon plans draft medics
Pentagon plans to close 33 major bases
Polls americans may 03 { May 13 2003 }
Polls show americans becoming isolationists
President to control special ops { August 13 2003 }
Reporter involved in soldiers question to rumsfeld
Rumsfeld angers france germany
Rumsfeld setup by reporter { December 8 2004 }
Soft economy helps recruiting effort { September 22 2003 }
State department told to retract report on global peace
Threatened war
United States biggest arms dealer as conflicts decrease { June 10 2004 }
United states skips landmine conference { November 28 2004 }
Us dispersed uranium 43 countries { March 7 2004 }
Us keeps intelligence from british
US overrules puetro rico on election { December 3 2004 }
Us plans to cut troops in europe by third { February 3 2004 }
US updated plans to draft medical workers { October 19 2004 }
War record lies { September 12 2002 }
Warcollege professor report compares waronterror to hitler { January 12 2004 }

Files Listed: 45



Correction/submissions

CIA FOIA Archive

National Security
Archives
Support one-state solution for Israel and Palestine Tea Party bumper stickers JFK for Dummies, The Assassination made simple