NewsMine — security — terror-suspects — detainees — Viewing Item

Secrecy dueprocess { October 25 1999 } Secrecy and Due Process Monday, October 25, 1999; Page A28 THE CASE OF Hany Mahmoud Kiareldeen is about as thorough an indictment of the use of secret evidence as one could ever expect to see. Mr. Kiareldeen, a Palestinian who has lived in this country since 1990, was arrested in March of last year. The government has sought to deport him and has used classified evidence to oppose his application for permanent residency and to keep him detained. No judge who has examined this evidence -- and the count stands at seven -- has deemed it a credible basis for his removal; a U.S. District judge this week even held that his continued incarceration based on secret evidence was unconstitutional. Yet Mr. Kiareldeen remains in custody, and the government continues to seek temporary stays of the various orders to release him. The secret evidence purportedly indicates that Mr. Kiareldeen was a member of a terrorist group, that he had been alleged by a single source to have hosted a meeting of the World Trade Center bombing conspirators and that a source also had claimed that he wanted to kill Attorney General Janet Reno. Mr. Kiareldeen has never been permitted to confront his accuser. But in immigration court, he nonetheless managed to poke serious holes in this supposed evidence. He presented numerous witnesses who testified that he didn't even live in the house at which he supposedly held the illicit meeting at the time the meeting took place, for example. And he showed that his ex-wife -- who had filed a string of dubious domestic violence charges against him -- was the likely source of the allegations against him. Testimony before the immigration court suggested that, far from being an Islamic fundamentalist, Mr. Kiareldeen was not especially religious -- he drinks alcohol and is married to a non-Muslim -- and not politically active either. Back in April the immigration court ruled that he should get permanent residency status and be released on bond pending any government appeal. The Immigration and Naturalization Service, however, got his release stayed while it appealed this ruling, and Mr. Kiareldeen's lawyers subsequently filed a habeas corpus petition. In the past week, one three-judge immigration review panel upheld the decision to make Mr. Kiareldeen a permanent resident. Another upheld the decision to release him on bond. And federal district Judge William Walls held in the habeas case that "the government's reliance on secret evidence violates the due process protections that the Constitution directs must be extended to all persons within the United States, citizens and resident aliens alike." Yet despite such consistent and total repudiation of the government's case, Mr. Kiareldeen remains detained. This case is another in a string of examples of secret-evidence cases collapsing upon the sort of close scrutiny the secrecy is intended to avoid. It is hard to escape the conclusion that a process as antithetical to our legal system as holding someone accountable in court on the basis of material he cannot directly attack can never be legitimate. © Copyright 1999 The Washington Post Company

British judges criticized { November 9 2002 } Commission clears saudi arabia from 911 involvement { June 17 2004 } Court rules names secret { June 17 2003 } Court seeks details on detainee { November 5 2003 } Detainee names Detainees rights Detainees sought suicides en masse { January 25 2005 } Detainment inquiry { August 17 2002 } Detroit detainee supported { December 14 2002 } Disappeared { October 30 2001 } Doj investigation problems detainees Fears us wil use torture lite { March 5 2003 } Federal appeals court defers on national security Held 8 months { June 12 2002 } High court asks response to secret florida detainee case Hrw denounces torture Hundreds rounded california Judge says guantanmo tribunal is unconstitutional Lawyer lashes patriot act { December 23 2002 } Many gitmo detainees not accused { February 9 2006 } Massive detention { November 4 2001 } More can be held { April 25 2003 } Muslims in guantanamo were sold by warlords { May 31 2005 } New rules shorten holding time for detained immigrants { April 14 2004 } Nj american jailed { January 3 2003 } No closed hearings { May 30 2002 } Pentagon moves to bar cia holding ghost detainees { April 28 2005 } Prisoners beated to death { March 7 2003 } Red cross criticizes detention { October 10 2003 } Report critical detainee roundup { May 30 2003 } Rumsfeld defends secret detentions Secrecy dueprocess { October 25 1999 } Secret evidence { October 21 1997 } Secret evidence2 { October 21 1997 } Sedition Supreme court tests president arbitrary detention powers Tape show abuse of 911 detainees { December 19 2003 } Torture questions terrorists Tribunal rules amy deter lawyers { July 13 2003 } Files Listed: 39

Correction/submissions

CIA FOIA Archive

National Security Archives

This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information, go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purpose of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.