News and Document archive source
copyrighted material disclaimer at bottom of page

NewsMinesecurityprison-incarcerationdeathpenalty — Viewing Item

Justice stevens cites serious flaws in use of death penalty { August 8 2005 }

Original Source Link: (May no longer be active)

Stevens Cites 'Serious Flaws' In Use of the Death Penalty

Associated Press
Monday, August 8, 2005; A04

CHICAGO -- Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens issued an unusually stinging criticism of capital punishment Saturday evening, telling the American Bar Association that he is disturbed by "serious flaws."

Stevens stopped short of calling for an end to the death penalty, but he said there are many problems in the way it is used.

Stevens said DNA evidence has shown "that a substantial number of death sentences have been imposed erroneously. . . . It indicates that there must be serious flaws in our administration of criminal justice," he said.

Death penalty cases dominate the work of the high court. Week after week justices deal with final emergency appeals, sometimes filed late at night.

In their last term, which ended in June, justices overturned the death sentences of four inmates, ruled that states cannot put to death killers who were not at least 18 years old at the time of the crime and held that it is unconstitutional to force defendants to appear before juries in chains during a trial's penalty phase.

Justices have four capital cases on their docket when they return to work in October, including a potentially significant issue of letting inmates have a new chance to prove their innocence with DNA evidence.

Other Supreme Court justices have also spoken out about concerns that defendants in murder cases are not adequately represented. But Stevens made a much harsher condemnation.

He said Supreme Court cases have revealed that "a significant number of defendants in capital cases have not been provided with fully competent legal representation at trial."

In addition, Stevens said he had reviewed records that showed "special risks of unfairness" in capital punishment.

Juries might not be balanced because people who have qualms about capital punishment can be excluded by prosecutors, he said. He questioned whether potential jurors are distracted by extensive questions about their death penalty views.

A statement from a victim's family, Stevens said, sometimes "serves no purpose other than to encourage jurors to decide in favor of death rather than life on the basis of their emotions rather than their reason."

2005 The Washington Post Company

1000th execution is white while black spared
8th ncarolina death row inmate freed { May 6 2008 }
Ashcroft pursues death { July 1 2002 }
California and florida suspend executions after botch
Court overturns 100 death sentences { September 2 2003 }
Death penalty flawed { June 12 2000 }
Death penalty suspended in new york
Death row evidence deliberately falsified by police { May 6 2006 }
Dna clears death row inmate { April 22 2003 }
Dna evidence destroyed in death penalty case { November 30 2005 }
Doctors refusal cause execution postponed indefinitely
Fed penalty unconstitutional { July 2 2002 }
Federal unconstitutional { September 24 2002 }
Governor orders innocence test of executed man { January 6 2006 }
Halt executions { May 16 2002 }
Innocent individuals are executed { August 11 2003 }
Jury only { June 25 2002 }
Justice stevens cites serious flaws in use of death penalty { August 8 2005 }
Lethal injections cause agonizingly painful deaths { April 15 2005 }
Md death penalty { May 10 2002 }
Md death racial { January 8 2003 }
Md study disparities
Mentally retarded { June 21 2002 }
Mounting evidence innocent people death penalty
North carolina executions on hold { February 20 2007 }
Us accuses germany undermining death penalty { November 14 2000 }
Us courts overturns 100 death sentences { September 2 2003 }
Us violated mexicans rights on death row
Witness clears man executed in texas in 1993 { November 22 2005 }

Files Listed: 29


CIA FOIA Archive

National Security
Support one-state solution for Israel and Palestine Tea Party bumper stickers JFK for Dummies, The Assassination made simple