News and Document archive source
copyrighted material disclaimer at bottom of page

NewsMinewar-on-terroriraqwar-crimesabu-Ghraib-prison — Viewing Item


Pentagon claims prisoner abuse lost us the war

Original Source Link: (May no longer be active)
   http://www.csmonitor.com/2004/0504/dailyUpdate.html

http://www.csmonitor.com/2004/0504/dailyUpdate.html
http://www.oneworld.net/article/view/85302/1/

Iraqi Prisoner Abuse May Undermine War on Terror
Tom Regan
Christian Science Monitor
04 May 2004

Regardless of the outcome of the now multiple investigations into prisoner abuse at Baghdad's Abu Ghraib prison, politicians and media around the world say the United States' image has suffered a serious blow. Sen. Joe Biden (D) of Delaware said on Fox News Sunday that "This is the single most significant undermining act that's occurred in a decade in that region of the world in terms of our standing."

The Associated Press reports that a senior Bush administration official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said the photos (of US soldiers abusing Iraqi prisoners) hurt the US efforts to win over an audience that is already deeply skeptical of US intentions. Arabs and Muslims, the official added, "are certain to seize upon the images as proof that the American occupiers are as brutal as ousted President Saddam Hussein's government."

Officials at the Defense Department are also said to be "livid," and well aware of the damage that has been done by the incident, according to NBC News' Pentagon reporter Jim Miklaszewski. Speaking on the Imus in the Morning radio/MSNBC program Tuesday , Mr. Miklaszewski said he asked a Pentagon contact about the soldiers alleged to be involved, to which the Pentagon official replied, "You mean the six morons who lost the war?"

The Chicago Tribune reports that other experts agree with this assessment.

"The United States already had a huge perception problem in the Arab world," said Stephen Walt, a professor of international affairs at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government. "This is only going to reinforce the belief that the United States is anti-Arab and anti-Muslim, whether it's true or not."
As the Financial Times noted, even before the incidents at Abu Ghraib, opinion polls taken in Iraq and other Muslim and non-Muslim nations "indicated an almost global nadir of US credibility and popularity." And the Times reports that the US's much hailed public relations campaign in the Middle East is "floundering."

The New York Times reported late last week that Margaret Tutwiler, the woman who was put in charge of the program to make changes in the US's "public diplomacy effort" announced she was leaving the job to take a position with the New York Stock Exchange. The Financial Times also reports that experts on the Middle East say public relations programs or new pro-US TV channels will not change the way people in the Arab world feel.

"It is not the case that Arabs and Muslims feel antipathy towards the US because they are being brainwashed by Al Jazeera or reading state-controlled media in Egypt – it's American policy," said Samer Shehata, professor of Arab politics at Georgetown University. "Regardless of how many radio stations you have that play great music, or TV stations like al-Hurra, as long as US policy - whether it be in Iraq or Palestine - remains the same you are not going to win hearts and minds."

Rashid Khalidi, director of the Middle East Institute at Columbia University, echoes this view.

"I think the United States is less respected at the end of these 13 months than it has ever been," he said. "Never has a country with such unlimited power been so pitifully unable to affect outcomes. Ruthless, murderous terrorists can strike at will in the United States and the US can't take Fallujah?"

In the same article, by Agence-France Presse, Robert Leiber, professor of government and foreign service at Georgetown University, argues, however, in favor of keeping "things in perspective."

"The photographs and, more importantly, the acts themselves are harmful to the cause of helping the Iraqis form a stable and democratic country," Leiber said, but he noted that such treatment is contrary to US policy. "We must keep in mind that, although this has been an ugly business, it pales in comparison to what Saddam (Hussein) did to his own people over 30 years," he said.

Unfortunately, many others believe that the damage has already been done. The allegation of mistreatment of prisoners "makes the US and coalition forces a legitimate enemy in the eyes of more Arabs than was the case before," said Anthony Cordesman, an expert on Middle East security issues at the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

Mr. Cordesman, in another interview with Reuters, said the mistreatment of Iraqi prisoners also hurts the war on terror. "Those Americans who mistreated the prisoners may not have realized it, but they acted in the direct interests of Al Qaeda, the insurgents, and the enemies of the US."

"These negative images validate all other negative images and interact with them," he [Cordesman] said in a statement, citing "careless US rhetoric about Arabs and Islam," failures to stabilize Iraq, continued Israeli-Palestinian violence and fears the United States is out to dominate the Middle East.

The Miami Herald, in an editorial, writes that the exposure of abuse at Abu Gharaib can "seriously damage" the success of US operations, both militarily and otherwise, in Iraq.

"It is too bad that the response so far, from President Bush's perfunctory indignation to General Myers' blaming a few wayward soldiers, badly misses the mark. The whole premise of the US invasion of Iraq (as currently construed) is to rid the Iraqi people of a brutal dictator and create a foothold for democracy in the Middle East. The senseless humiliation and abuse of Iraqi prisoners – many of whom were civilians and have since been released without charges – is an indelible stain on that endeavor."

Yet in the end, The Christian Science Monitor reported Monday, this latest incident may not have made all that much difference to many in the Arab world because their opinion of the US had already sunk as low as it could. That is why, argues Rami Khouri, a Jordanian political analyst and editor of Lebanon's Daily Star, the only thing that will substantially change the US's image in the Muslim world, is a change of policies.

"They [the US] have to be more even-handed in the Arab-Israeli issue, be less militaristic in addressing regimes they don't like, be more consistent in promoting democracy everywhere not only in a few places," Khouri says. "They can turn their image around, but only if they turn their policies into more consistently fair and reasonable ones."



Abu ghraib general claims conspiracy { August 3 2004 }
Abu ghraib general says she met israeli
Abu ghraib general says shes scapegoat { June 15 2004 }
Abu ghraib is a protected crime scene says judge { June 21 2004 }
Abu ghraib medic covered up homicide
Abu graib dog handler says he followed orders { March 22 2006 }
Abu graib prisoners pushed to stroke or heart attack
Abuse aproved by rumsfeld
Army clears top abu ghraib case officers
Army destroyed mock execution pictures
Army doctors had role in abuse { August 19 2004 }
Army doctors implicated in abuse { January 6 2005 }
Army report on abu ghraib faults military intelligence
Blood gushed from prisoner mouth like faucet
British soldiers shocking and appalling abuse { January 18 2005 }
Bush apologizes to jordan king for iraqi prisoner abuse { May 6 2004 }
Bush was informed of red cross concerns { May 12 2004 }
Cbs to air soldiers diary of abuse on second 60minutes
Cia sought contractors for interrogators { May 12 2004 }
CIA spurned prison rules report says { August 26 2004 }
Colorado senates think detainee photos shouldnt be released { May 13 2004 }
Conresswomen sees prisoners with inflected wounds { May 13 2004 }
Contractors in iraq face classaction lawsuit { June 10 2004 }
Dog handlers sanctioned by chain of command { May 23 2006 }
Dogs attack naked iraqi prisoner [jpg]
Elderly woman ridden like a donkey { May 6 2004 }
England following orders
England says she took orders from military intelligence { August 4 2004 }
Excessive force abuse to iraqi prisoners { May 11 2004 }
Family defends reservist woman in prison photos { May 4 2004 }
Film shows young prisoners sodomised
Further abuse detailed { October 23 2004 }
Generals told MPs to soften up prisoners { May 8 2004 }
Ghost detainees off the books
Graner lawyer points finger at chain of command { January 7 2005 }
Graner questioned orders and was told it was legal
Graner upset lynn pled guilty { May 4 2005 }
Guilty sergeant says military intelligence oversaw abuse { October 21 2004 }
Harsh CIA methods cited in top interrogations { May 13 2004 }
Inmate says graner laughed during abuse
Intel staffer says army concealed involvement in abuse { May 18 2004 }
Intelligence officer asked guard to humiliate detainees
Intelligence officer faces charges from abu ghraib { September 11 2004 }
Interrogation methods violated geneva rules { May 13 2004 }
Iraqi abuse widespread routine says redcross
Iraqi died while hanging by wrists { February 17 2005 }
Iraqi ghost detainees could number 100 { September 10 2004 }
Iraqi on leash [jpg]
Iraqi prisoners murdered { May 4 2004 }
Iraqi prisoners story like catch 22 { May 28 2004 }
Iraqi sues contractors over abu ghraib torture { May 5 2008 }
Iraqi teens abused at abu ghraib { August 24 2004 }
Israeli torture template
Judge orders government to release damning abu ghraib videos { June 3 2005 }
Judge rejects military intelligence testimony { October 23 2004 }
Knowledge of abuse may go higher
Lawmakers shocked by evidence of abuse { May 12 2004 }
Lawmakers view violent and sexual mistreatment of inmates { May 13 2004 }
Lawyers call rumsfeld cheney to abuse hearing { June 4 2004 }
Lynndie england gets 3 years while officers not charged { September 27 2005 }
Lynndie england hearing for august
Lynndie england is a new mother { October 13 2004 }
Lynndie England orgy at abu Ghraib { May 13 2004 }
Lynndie says she was government puppet { February 2008 }
Military intelligence behind abuse { May 20 2004 }
Military intelligence ordered prisoners hidden from red cross { August 5 2004 }
Military police photograph female soldiers while showering
Military takes action against key witness in abu ghraib { May 21 2004 }
Military torture scandal [jpg]
Military torture scandal2 [jpg]
Military torture scandal3 [jpg]
Military torture scandal4 [jpg]
More photos video in iraq abuse scandal says rumseld
More prisoners released { May 21 2004 }
Naked soldier covered in feces [jpg]
Navy seals abuse [jpg]
Navy seals bloody prisoners
Navyseal abuse [jpg]
New details emerge with new set of photos released { May 21 2004 }
New images of abu graib abuse are broadcast in australia { February 15 2006 }
No charges for murdering prisoners { March 26 2005 }
Outrage at maerican torture of iraqi prisoners
Pentagon claims prisoner abuse lost us the war
Photos of dead iraqi prisoners raise questions { May 7 2004 }
Photos of prisoners naked simulating sex { April 28 2004 }
Photos of soldiers with dead prisoners { May 19 2004 }
Press is obsessed with abuse story { May 21 2004 }
Prisoner guards scapegoated in abuse { May 9 2004 }
Prisoner had electrical wires to his genitals
Prisoner sodomized by glow sticks
Prisoners given electric shocks
Probe points to failures of leadership of top brass { August 20 2004 }
Punches iraqi prisoners [jpg]
Redcross asked for investigation for prisoner abuse
Redcross told abuse is part of the process { May 10 2004 }
Report blames pentagon neglection
Report on abuse faults 2 intelligence officers { May 3 2004 }
Reservist pleads not guilty to kicking pow to death { August 24 2004 }
Rumsfeld approved iraq interrogation plan { May 15 2004 }
Rush limbaugh says prisoner abuse not serious { May 6 2004 }
Saddams judge kept secret for safety sake
Scandal bigger than prison abuse { May 6 2004 }
Senators suspect higher ups directed abuses at abu ghraib { May 12 2004 }
Soldier gets one year in abuse of iraqis { May 20 2004 }
Soldiers abuse iraqis for fun court told
Story papers cnn [jpg]
Top general in iraq authorized interrogation techniques { March 30 2005 }
Torture at abu ghraib
Torture was encouraged by military intelligence services
Troops sodomized iraqi boys
Two more prisoner deaths { May 5 2004 }
Uk forces taught torture methods { May 8 2004 }
Unreleased photos of prisoners beaten to death
Us forces taught torture techniques { May 14 2004 }
US general concedes abuse was torture { August 27 2004 }
US spies urged abuse of prisoners
Videos amplify picture of violence { May 21 2004 }
Washington post displays new iraqi abuse photos { May 6 2004 }
Witness says CIA oversaw abu ghraib abuse { October 21 2004 }
Witness to abuse trying to be heard { August 20 2004 }

Files Listed: 120



Correction/submissions

CIA FOIA Archive

National Security
Archives
Support one-state solution for Israel and Palestine Tea Party bumper stickers JFK for Dummies, The Assassination made simple