News and Document archive source
copyrighted material disclaimer at bottom of page

NewsMinewar-on-terroriraqpretextwmd — Viewing Item


No weapons found in iraq says report

Original Source Link: (May no longer be active)
   http://www.bayarea.com/mld/mercurynews/news/6922989.htm

http://www.bayarea.com/mld/mercurynews/news/6922989.htm

Posted on Fri, Oct. 03, 2003

No weapons found in Iraq, report says
INSPECTOR SAYS HUNT ISN'T OVER; REACTION IN CONGRESS IS MIXED
By Warren P. Strobel and Jim Kuhnhenn
Knight Ridder

WASHINGTON - The head of a CIA team hunting for weapons of mass destruction in Iraq told Congress on Thursday that he had not found any stockpiles of the chemical or biological arms that President Bush cited as the primary reason to invade Iraq in March.

But David Kay, a former U.N. weapons inspector, cautioned the House and Senate intelligence committees that his report was an interim one and that it was still possible weapons would be found. He said he found evidence that Iraq continued weapons development in violation of U.N. strictures.

Kay, whose teams have been scouring Iraq and interviewing captured Iraqi officials for three months, also reported that specialists found no evidence that Iraq's nuclear weapons program had progressed beyond a rudimentary stage.

That program was cited by Bush, Vice President Dick Cheney and others as perhaps the most fearsome threat posed by former Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein.

Kay's report is likely to intensify the debate over whether the administration intentionally misled the public on the threat posed by Iraq's weapons programs.

``We have not yet found stocks of weapons, but we are not yet at the point where we can say definitively either that such weapons stocks do not exist or that they existed before the war, and our only task is to find where they have gone,'' Kay said in an unclassified version of his testimony released by the CIA.

Members of his Iraq Survey Group, Kay said, have discovered weapons ``activities'' and equipment that were concealed from U.N. inspectors when they returned to Iraq late last year. Those include apparent biological weapons research and Iraqi attempts between 1999 and 2002 to import technology for 900-mile range missiles from North Korea, he said.

Reaction from intelligence committee members ranged from support for Kay's work to frustration over the limited findings, to dismay that one of the central justifications for war had not been proved.

``This raises real questions about the doctrine of pre-emption,'' said Sen. Jay Rockefeller, of West Virginia, the ranking Democrat on the Senate intelligence committee. ``You just don't make decisions like we do and put our nation's youth at risk based upon something that appears not to have existed.''

The committee chair, Sen. Pat Roberts, R-Kan., declared himself ``not pleased with what I heard today.''

``Everybody involved in this effort would have hoped by now there would have been a breakthrough,'' he said.

But Rep. Porter Goss, chair of the House panel, said Kay's report showed Bush's decision to remove Saddam was justified. ``From the information uncovered to date, it is clear that the threat Saddam presented to the region and to the world was real, growing and grave,'' said Goss, R-Fla.

Bush aides said Thursday that they still expect to find proof that Saddam possessed weapons of mass destruction.

``I have not seen anything that leads me to believe that the intelligence that I relied on is necessarily, in the aggregate, inaccurate,'' said Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld. ``I believed it then. I believe it now.''

Kay said interviews with Iraqi scientists confirmed that the Iraqi leader remained committed to acquiring atomic arms, perhaps after U.N. sanctions were lifted.

But Kay, speaking to reporters after his testimony, said evidence to date indicated ``a restart'' of the nuclear program -- which was halted by the 1991 Persian Gulf War -- was only ``at the very most rudimentary level.''

``It clearly does not look like a massive resurgent program,'' he said.

The comments contradicted earlier statements from Bush and Cheney. In August 2002, Cheney said Saddam ``will acquire nuclear weapons fairly soon.'' And in an October 2002 speech on Iraq, Bush said threats to the United States ``could come in the form of a mushroom cloud.''

Kay's report did not clear up the mystery of the mobile tractor-trailers discovered after the war, which the CIA has said were intended for use as mobile biological weapons production facilities.

``We have not yet been able to corroborate the existence of a mobile BW production effort,'' Kay said in his testimony. Two trailers found in northern Iraq in April could be for biological weapons or for less nefarious uses, such as producing hydrogen or rocket propellant, he said.

Rockefeller said Kay suggested that his work could take six to nine months to complete. The administration reportedly has requested $600 million more for the weapons search.

But some critics said the report shows that the U.N. weapons-inspection program that had been derided by the Bush administration had been successful and that the U.N. specialists should be brought back.

``As it turns out, the threat was effectively contained by inspections and by sanctions,'' said Joseph Cirincione, a weapons expert for the Washington-based Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. As for U.N. inspections, ``it will cost a lot less than $600 million,'' Cirincione said.

Knight Ridder correspondent Jonathan S. Landay contributed to this report.



tubes
uranium
weapons-declaration
Blair admits weapons may never be found { January 12 2004 }
Blair admits wmds may never be found { July 6 2004 }
Blair decided regime change april 2002 despite rhetoric { May 2 2005 }
Blix accuses fabricating evidence { April 12 2003 }
Blix report doubts wmd { June 2 2003 }
British doctored wmd dossier { May 29 2003 }
Bush declines to back call for intelligence probe
Bush jokes about finding wmds
Bush says war worth it despite no wmds
Bush says weapons will be found
Chemical weapons plant created after invasion { August 14 2005 }
Children play with uranium tubes
Cia condemned for flawed intelligence
Cia operative asked to falsify wmd report { December 9 2004 }
Classified study doubts weapons in 2002
Documents concerning uranium came from italy { October 25 2005 }
Fbi says profit motivated italian uranium forgery
Germ trailer evidence rejected { June 7 2003 }
GWB_WMD_Memo [pdf]
Inspector reports iraq had no WMD
Iraq declared al samoud missiles { April 29 2003 }
Iraq destroyed wmd 1995
Iraq may have destroyed wmd { May 27 2003 }
Kay blames cia for no wmd
Kurds help find wmd lab { May 7 2003 }
Mccain picked for iraq intelligence probe
Might have to be planted
New inspections to plant weapons { April 8 2003 }
New reports on us planting wmds in iraq
No firm evidence banned weapons { April 7 2003 }
No reliable evidence of iraqi weapons { June 6 2003 }
No reliable information wmd { June 6 2003 }
No weapons found in iraq says report
No wmd found but { February 14 2003 }
No wmds found in iraq { September 24 2003 }
Nuclear program materials still buried { June 26 2003 }
Officer refused falsify wmd reports
Panel assails CIA for failure on iraq weapons { March 29 2005 }
Powell says new data may have affected war decision { February 3 2004 }
Powell says wmd stocks wont be found
Powell says wmd un speech blot on record
Presidential report is critical of intelligence agencies
Questions on blair intelligence { April 21 2003 }
Report says intel on wmd was dead wrong { March 31 2005 }
Rockefeller says weapons should been found { May 29 2003 }
Saddam had no weapons in 2003 { October 6 2004 }
Saddam says wmd excuse for war
Scientist says arms kept till war { April 21 2003 }
Scientist surrenders says no wmd
Search for wmds in iraq ended last month { January 12 2005 }
Sen Durbin jan 26 06 on iraq wmds [mp3]
Sen Durbin jan 26 06 on iraq wmds
Senate panel blames bad iraq intelligence on CIA
Senators told iraqi weapons could hit east coast
Seniors sources ruled out finding wmds { July 10 2003 }
Skepticism on bushs weapons claims grow { May 22 2003 }
Smoking gun wmd site just pesticide
Task force unable find wmd { May 11 2003 }
Team hunting iraq WMD ends its search { January 12 2005 }
Test barrels nerve agent
Us adds teams hunt { April 27 2003 }
Us not inspected iraq nuclear facility { April 25 2003 }
US team concludes saddam had no wmd { April 26 2005 }
Us withdraws team of weapons hunters { January 8 2004 }
Usa and uk lied war pretext
Usa will falsify wmd
Weapons hunter quits says doubts they exist
Wmd intelligence was falisified { February 15 2004 }
Wmd proof [jpg]

Files Listed: 69



Correction/submissions

CIA FOIA Archive

National Security
Archives
Support one-state solution for Israel and Palestine Tea Party bumper stickers JFK for Dummies, The Assassination made simple