|
Yushchenko was poisoned doctors say { December 12 2004 } Original Source Link: (May no longer be active)
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A58049-2004Dec11.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A58049-2004Dec11.html
Correction to This Article
In some Dec. 12 editions, an article about the illness of Ukrainian presidential candidate Viktor Yushchenko incorrectly said that Paul M. Wax is affiliated with the American College of Toxicology. He is with the American College of Medical Toxicology. The article also gave an incorrect year for his contact with two Russian scientists who said they had investigated the potential of developing dioxin as a chemical weapon. That contact took place in 2002, not 1992.
Yushchenko Was Poisoned, Doctors Say
Ukrainian's Illness Caused by Dioxin
By Peter Finn
Washington Post Foreign Service
Sunday, December 12, 2004; Page A01
KIEV, Ukraine, Dec. 11 -- The illness that disfigured the face of opposition presidential candidate Viktor Yushchenko resulted from poisoning by the toxic substance dioxin, which might have been placed deliberately in his food, Austrian doctors who treated him told reporters in Vienna on Saturday.
"The criminal investigation does not fit within our purview but . . . there is suspicion of third-party involvement," said Michael Zimpfer, director of Vienna's private Rudolfinerhaus clinic, where the candidate went for treatment in September after falling ill while campaigning.
The face of the once youthful-looking Yushchenko, 50, was mysteriously transformed into a blotch of lesions after he reached Austria. He also suffered severe abdominal and back pain and paralysis on the left side of his face. His appearance has continued to worsen, raising public concern about his health despite his claims he is fully recovering.
Yushchenko contends he was poisoned in an assassination attempt by "government officials" who feared that he would defeat Prime Minister Viktor Yanukovych in elections. His opponents have dismissed the charge, saying he got sick after gorging himself on bad sushi and too much alcohol.
Yanukovych was officially declared the winner of a Nov. 21 runoff vote. The country's Supreme Court soon overturned the result, citing widespread poll fraud, and a new election will be held on Dec. 26.
The Austrian doctors said on Saturday that Yushchenko's long-term prognosis was good, though it could take several years for his face to heal. For now, Yushchenko is "fully capable of working," said Nikolai Korpan, another doctor.
"If this dose had been higher, it may have caused death," Zimpfer said, noting the dioxin could have been administered through food such as soup.
Dioxins are a group of organic compounds that contain chlorine. They are a common byproduct in the manufacture of many industrial chemicals, and are also a common contaminant from waste incineration. They are a component of the Vietnam-era defoliant Agent Orange and many researchers have labeled them a cause of cancer and other diseases among people living in areas where the defoliant was used.
Debate over dioxins' potency as a poison, as opposed to a cancer-causing agent, has swirled for decades. But the compounds are known to cause reproductive and developmental problems, in addition to extreme skin eruptions known as chloracne.
Documented cases of acute dioxin poisoning are rare.
One notable case occurred in Seveso, Italy, in 1976, when an explosion at a Hoffman-LaRoche chemical plant released a cloud of the herbicide 2,4,5-T, exposing several thousand people to the chemical and an estimated 45 pounds of dioxins, which typically arise as a byproduct in the synthesis of 2,4,5-T.
Many people near the plant developed severe skin problems within hours. In the months that followed, many who experienced heavy exposures developed chloracne. Another case occurred in 1997 in Vienna, where two employees of a textile institute developed chloracne on their bodies, according to Olaf Paepke, a scientist at a Hamburg institute, who conducted chemical analysis for the investigation. The employees had levels of dioxin in their systems thousands of times higher than normally found. Police were never able to determine how the poisoning occurred, including if it was deliberate or accidental, Paepke said. The employees survived.
Dioxins are not commercially available, Paepke said, but can be obtained through industry contacts or made in a laboratory by people with the proper skills. A tiny, unnoticeable amount placed in food is sufficient to cause severe illness, he said.
Arnold Schecter, a dioxin expert at the University of Texas School of Public Health at Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas, said dioxins can be highly effective poison in people who are sensitive to their effects. If Yushchenko was deliberately given dioxin, it was done by someone who "was very clever and very knowledgeable," Schecter said.
"If someone put a drop of pure dioxin in his food, he wouldn't taste it, he wouldn't see it and a few days later he'd start to get sick," Schecter said.
"If you are trying to kill someone quickly, it's not the way to go," he said. "But if you want to disable someone and want to do it subtly and have it happen days or weeks or months after you have contact with someone, this can do it," Schecter said. "Plus there are very few labs in the world that can accurately detect dioxin in the blood."
Paul M. Wax, with the American College of Medical Toxicology, said two scientists he met in Volgograd, Russia, in 2002 told him that during the Soviet era they had investigated the potential of developing dioxin as a chemical weapon.
Wax expressed doubts that dioxin could be used in that way. "It was never on anyone's list," said Wax, a physician who now teaches courses on chemical terrorism. "We don't think about it as an acute poison that can kill you. . . . It's not going to cause someone to keel over on a battlefield," but could cause long-term illness.
A Russian government specialist challenged the Vienna doctors' findings. "It is impossible to get a dose of dioxin today and get poisoning tomorrow," said Yury Ostapenko, head of the Toxicology Information Center at the Russian Health Ministry, speaking on the Echo Moskvy radio station. "Dioxins do not belong to immediate-effect poisons: Poisoning develops for years and decades."
Doctors at the Austrian clinic had declined for weeks to issue a finding on the cause of the illness but said Saturday that tests conducted in an Amsterdam hospital had confirmed the presence of dioxin.
Yushchenko flew to Austria on Friday for further tests at the clinic. "What happened to me was an attempt to politically destroy a politician with opposing views," he said at a news conference in Kiev on Friday, shortly before his departure. "The aim was to kill me."
Speaking to 5,000 supporters in the city of Luhansk before the announcement in Vienna, Yanukovych said of Yushchenko: "He certainly is ill and I sympathize. Let him get well soon. As for the reasons, I know nothing. Let the specialists work on that."
After the statement was issued, there was no immediate response from the Yanukovych campaign, whose press secretary resigned Friday night, the latest in a series of defections. But Yanukovych's attorney before the Supreme Court, Stepan Havrysh, said: "I'm afraid, two weeks before the vote, it's all political technologies," the Associated Press reported.
Yushchenko supporters said the finding bore out what they had long believed.
"This official confirmation is another opportunity to speak the truth to the Ukrainian people and to show one more time the dirty methods that were used by the authorities," said Yuri Yekhanurov, a member of parliament, in a telephone interview.
In Vienna, Yushchenko struck an upbeat note Saturday. "I plan to live for a long time and I plan to live happily," he said. "I am getting better . . . every day."
Staff Writers Rob Stein, Rick Weiss, Juliet Eilperin, Joby Warrick and John Burgess in Washington contributed to this report.
|
|
