News and Document archive source
copyrighted material disclaimer at bottom of page

NewsMinewar-on-terroriraqsaddam-husseintrial — Viewing Item


Saddam yells at judge in unruly session { November 2005 }

Original Source Link: (May no longer be active)
   http://apnews.myway.com/article/20051205/D8EA32D81.html

http://apnews.myway.com/article/20051205/D8EA32D81.html

Saddam Yells at Judge in Unruly Session
Dec 5, 7:23 AM (ET)

By HAMZA HENDAWI

BAGHDAD, Iraq (AP) - Saddam Hussein's defense team walked out of court Monday, the former leader yelled at the judge, and Saddam's half brother shouted "Why don't you just execute us!" in an often unruly court session that also saw former U.S. Attorney General Ramsey Clark speak on behalf of the deposed president.

After the lawyers walked out, Saddam, shaking his right hand, told the judge: "You are imposing lawyers on us. They are imposed lawyers. The court is imposed by itself. We reject that."

Clark said he needed only two minutes to present his argument. But Chief Judge Rizgar Mohammed Amin at first said only Saddam's chief lawyer could speak. Amin said the defense should submit its motion in writing and warned that if the defense walked out then the court would appoint replacement lawyers.

Saddam and his half brother Barazan Ibrahim then chanted "Long live Iraq, long live the Arab state."

Ibrahim stood up and shouted: "Why don't you just execute us and get rid of all of this!"

When the judge explained that he was ruling in accordance with the law, Saddam replied: "This is a law made by America and does not reflect Iraqi sovereignty."

It was the third court session in the trial of Saddam and seven co-defendants - accused in the 1982 killing of more than 140 Shiites after an assassination attempt against the president in Dujail - where Saddam at times appeared to be in control of the court as much as the judge presiding over the trial.

After the walk-out and a 90-minute recess to resolve the issue, the court reconvened and Amin allowed Clark and ex-Qatari Justice Minister Najib al-Nueimi to speak on the questions of the legitimacy of the tribunal and safety of the lawyers.

"Reconciliation is essential," Clark told the court. "This trial can divide or heal. Unless it is seen as absolutely fair, and fair in fact, it will divide rather than reconcile Iraq."

At that point the judge reminded Clark that he was to speak only about the security guarantees for the defense lawyers - two of whom have been assassinated since the trial began Oct. 19.

Clark then said all parties were entitled to protection and the measures offered to protect the defense and their families were "absurd." Clark said that without such protection, the judicial system would collapse.

Al-Nueimi then spoke about the legitimacy issue, arguing that court is not independent and was in fact set up under the U.S.-led occupation rather than by a legal Iraqi government. He said the language of the statute was unchanged from that promulgated by the former top U.S. administrator in Iraq, L. Paul Bremer, and was therefore "illegitimate."

After the lawyers spoke, the first witness to take the stand, Ahmed Hassan Mohammed, began his testimony. He said that after an assassination attempt on Saddam, security agencies took people of all ages from age 14 to over age 70.

"There were mass arrests. Women and men. Even if a child was 1-day-old they used to tell his parents, 'Bring him with you,"' Mohammed said. He said he was taken to a security center where "I saw bodies of people from Dujail."

"They were martyrs I knew," Mohammed said, giving the name of the nine whose bodies were there.

The first witness earlier exchanged insults with Saddam's half brother, telling him "you killed a 14-year-old boy."

"To hell," the half brother, Ibrahim, replied.

"You and your children go to hell," the witness replied.

The judge then asked them to avoid such exchanges.

"There was random arrests in the streets, all the forces of the (Baath) party, and Thursday became 'Judgment Day' and Dujail has become a battle front," the witness said, sometime fighting back tears. "Shootings started and nobody could leave or enter Dujail. At night, intelligence agents arrived headed by Barazan" Ibrahim.

At this point Ibrahim interrupted him, saying that "I am a patriot and I was the head of the intelligence service of Iraq."




1100 lawyers leave saddam defense team { November 13 2005 }
Annan rejects any trial with execution
Another saddam defense lawyer slain
Bush favors ultimate penalty for saddam
Changes of saddam trail in 2004 remote
Cia will interrogate saddam hussein { December 18 2003 }
Death penalty for saddam faces critics
Defense team and saddam walk out of trial { December 2006 }
Iraq tribunal charges saddam for trial
Judge lawyer on saddam tribunal killed
Judges try to remove appointed saddam judge { December 2006 }
Lawyer in saddam trial found dead { October 22 2005 }
Lawyer representing saddam hussein killed { May 2006 }
Lawyer seeks three month adjourment
Lawyers threaten to boycott saddam trial
New saddam judge brother in law killed { August 2006 }
No smoking gun in saddam trial { June 8 2004 }
Official held in saddam hanging recording { December 2007 }
Prospects for saddam trial still uncertain
Rumsfeld says old friend saddam have protections { December 15 2003 }
Saddam alive [jpg]
Saddam and 11 aides turned over to new iraq government { June 30 2004 }
Saddam and lawyers boycotted trial { January 2006 }
Saddam codefendant lawyer kidnapped { October 20 2005 }
Saddam could die before trial { July 29 2004 }
Saddam dec19 04 fake ap [jpg]
Saddam defense team kept in the dark
Saddam defiant july1 [jpg]
Saddam fed by tube during hunger strike
Saddam files new human rights complaint { July 23 2004 }
Saddam hanging dec 30 2006 [jpg]
Saddam hanging shown with grainy footage { November 2006 }
Saddam in good health spirits even though dead
Saddam { June 2004 } [jpg]
Saddam kidnapped says international law { January 10 2004 }
Saddam lawyer call for delay in trial { January 2006 }
Saddam lawyers claim american support during atrocities
Saddam major atrocities dismissed after hanging { November 2006 }
Saddam meets with lawyers one year after arrest
Saddam moved to qatar over rescue fears
Saddam on tape complaining july 05 [jpg]
Saddam sacks legal team
Saddam scoffs at charges of war crimes { July 1 2004 }
Saddam sentenced to death just before 2006 elections { November 6 2006 }
Saddam shown warcrimes video { December 18 2003 }
Saddam stroke
Saddam trial is missing saddam
Saddam trial judge plans to quit { December 2005 }
Saddam trial may be delayed again { November 8 2005 }
Saddam trial to resume after dec 2005 elections
Saddam yells at judge in unruly session { November 2005 }
Supposedly saddam confesses { September 7 2005 }
Team says saddam in fight in court room { July 30 2005 }
Team sent to develop case in trial in iraq { March 7 2004 }
Third judge appointed after delay { January 24 2006 }
Tribunal disagree with us on saddam handoff
Two hussein allies are hanged one decepitated { January 15 2007 }
Us sends team to make case against saddam
Video released of saddam decries panel
Whitehouse denies hussein verdict timed with elections
World community boycotts saddam trial says rice

Files Listed: 61



Correction/submissions

CIA FOIA Archive

National Security
Archives
Support one-state solution for Israel and Palestine Tea Party bumper stickers JFK for Dummies, The Assassination made simple