News and Document archive source
copyrighted material disclaimer at bottom of page

NewsMinecabal-elitew-administrationbush-team — Viewing Item


Powell under fire { April 24 2003 }

Original Source Link: (May no longer be active)
   http://www.nytimes.com/2003/04/24/international/worldspecial/24POWE.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2003/04/24/international/worldspecial/24POWE.html

April 24, 2003
Under Fire, Powell Receives Support From White House
By STEVEN R. WEISMAN


WASHINGTON, April 23 - Since the end of the war in Iraq, Secretary of State Colin L. Powell has come under intense fire from conservatives within the administration, in Congress and at policy institutes long favoring less diplomacy and more muscle in the American approach to the world.

On issues from the Middle East to North Korea to the makeup of a postwar government in Iraq, Mr. Powell and the State Department have been battling hard-liners at the Pentagon and in Vice President Dick Cheney's office, administration officials say.

In the face of conservative criticism, Mr. Powell has won approval from President Bush for negotiating with Syria on its support of terrorism, negotiating with North Korea on its nuclear weapons program, and promoting talks between Israel and a newly emerging Palestinian leadership to create a Palestinian state.

All those policies have drawn fire in recent weeks, most recently from the former speaker of the House, Newt Gingrich, who spoke at the American Enterprise Institute on Tuesday and issued a blistering attack on Mr. Powell's stewardship of the State Department.

Mr. Powell has been the object of conservative criticism in several past policy battles, but the barrage was renewed with particular bitterness in recent days. Aides to Mr. Powell said they regarded some of the recent attacks as both puzzling and misguided, noting that the secretary had been extremely careful not to undertake any initiatives without explicit approval from the president.

A senior White House official, asserted today that Mr. Gingrich's criticism "was seen at the White House as an attack on the president, not an attack on Powell." There was widespread anger at the White House, the official said, but he declined to characterize the reaction of Mr. Bush himself.

However, the president is said by Republican politicians to have little love for Mr. Gingrich, going back to Mr. Gingrich's savage attack against Mr. Bush's father for raising taxes, a step that ignited the wrath of conservatives generally.

While dismissing Mr. Gingrich's comments, State Department officials said today that they wondered whether Mr. Gingrich might have checked with someone in the administration before launching his attack.

The former speaker serves on the Defense Policy Board along with other prominent conservatives and is known to be close to Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld and Mr. Cheney.

But a Pentagon spokesman said that to the best of his knowledge, no one at the Defense Department had seen Mr. Gingrich's speech or was familiar with its content ahead of time. An administration official said Mr. Cheney had also not seen the speech.

Both Ari Fleischer, the White House spokesman, and Richard A. Boucher, the State Department spokesman, dismissed Mr. Gingrich's remarks as misinformed and wrong. Mr. Fleischer called Mr. Powell an "able, able diplomat" who was carrying out "the president's approach" on foreign policy in a successful manner.

Nevertheless, officials acknowledged that there had been a number of tussles recently, some of them possibly because the administration's hard-liners and advocates of the war with Iraq seemed emboldened in the wake of the victory last month. Divisions between the State Department and the Pentagon have been a recurring theme in this administration, but in the period leading up to the war in Iraq there seemed to be an effort to present a united front. That unity is once again cracked.

On North Korea, for example, Mr. Rumsfeld made clear that he opposed talks with the North Korean government that began this week in Beijing. Instead, Mr. Rumsfeld circulated a memorandum proposing that China and the United States try to bring down the government of Kim Jong Il, the North Korean leader. In addition, Mr. Rumsfeld unsuccessfully pushed for a more conservative State Department official, John R. Bolton, to lead the talks, administration officials said.

In Iraq, the Defense Department had initially sought to promote as the new leaders of the country a group of exiles with whom Mr. Rumsfeld and his deputy, Paul D. Wolfowitz, had been in close contact. The Defense Department allowed military forces to move the group's leader, Ahmad Chalabi, into Iraq to help rally Iraqis behind him.

Subsequently, the White House made clear - at the request of the State Department, according to many officials - that the United States would make no effort to install any particular Iraqis in power in Baghdad.

Two other divisive issues on which Mr. Powell has been attacked by conservatives involve Syria and Israel. Mr. Powell's recent announcement that he would discuss the problem of Syria's support for terrorism and possession of dangerous weapons in Damascus with President Bashar al-Assad was criticized by Mr. Gingrich as "ludicrous."

But administration officials said today that Mr. Bush had cleared the Powell announcement and that both Mr. Cheney and Condoleezza Rice, the national security adviser, had advocated toning down the criticism of Syria.

The administration's policies on Israel have drawn fire from many quarters, including Representative Tom DeLay of Texas, the House majority leader, who has labeled them "diplomatic mumbo jumbo." His criticism was directed at the peace plan drafted by the United States and three partners - the United Nations, the European Union and Russia - for a staged process leading to a Palestinian state, in return for security guarantees and an end to violence against Israelis.

Administration officials said today that the plan would be published soon - now that the Palestinians have selected a prime minister - and that the approach had Mr. Bush's full support.

Mr. Powell was the administration's strongest advocate of enlisting the United Nations to support the use of force in Iraq and negotiating with France toward that end. Those negotiations failed, and Mr. Powell said this week that France would have to face unspecified "consequences" of its opposition.

Aides said today that while Mr. Powell felt strongly that France needed to be informed of American displeasure, any actions to punish France should not also punish the United States by making further cooperation impossible in Iraq or elsewhere.



Copyright 2003 The New York Times Company | Home | Privacy Policy | Search | Corrections | Help | Back to Top


ashcroft
cheney
chertoff
condoleezza
ehrlich
gonzales
kerik
negroponte
perle
porter-goss
rumsfeld
Abrams iran contra mideast role { May 27 2003 }
Army secretary enron { May 2 2003 }
Author of nclb confirmed as secretary of education
Bolton arranged unlawful firing in 2002 { June 5 2005 }
Bush and ken lay { April 7 2004 }
Bush appoints bolton during senate recess { August 1 2005 }
Bush energy secretary bush top polluters { January 16 2005 }
Bush feels debrated by senior whitehouse aides
Bush fires cia chief tenet
Bush has overnight fundraisers whitehouse camp david
Bush lieberman kiss [jpg]
Bush official supports abortions for blacks
Bush oz team [jpg]
Bush picks loyalists for education cousel jobs
Bush plants kiss on liebermans cheek
Bush praises and quotes lieberman in speech { December 7 2005 }
Bush saudi friends [jpg]
Bush scrutinizes advisors { December 23 2002 }
Bush senior carlyle board { April 7 2003 }
Bush team now disagrees on foreign policy { February 1 2008 }
Bush urges senate to confirm bolton for UN { April 21 2005 }
Bush uses ken lay lawyer { July 12 2004 }
Bush wants wolfowitz heading the world bank
Cabal whos who { March 22 2003 }
Cabinet changes likely in bush 2nd term { November 4 2004 }
Cheney and bush drift apart
Cheney avoided vietnam war with 5 deferments { November 18 2005 }
Cheney could face charges in shooting if victim dies
Cheney friend says he doesnt know him anymore
Cheney gets defensive on iraq intelligence
Cheney is vice president for torture says cia director
Cheney leads whitehouse to allow torture
Cheney wants cia exempt from torture restrictions { October 25 2005 }
CIA loses two top leaders { June 5 2004 }
Conservative bloomberg columnist hates cheney
Convincted felons callings shots white house { August 7 2003 }
Dci george tenet resigns bush administration { June 3 2004 }
Delay linked political donations to legislative favor { October 7 2004 }
Ex nypd replaces tom ridge { December 3 2004 }
Fleischer resigns { May 19 2003 }
Gonzales new top cop approved torture { November 10 2004 }
Harris lands key role
Hersh calls administration straussians
Homeland security pick withdrawn because illegal housekeeper
House gop stops ethics rule change for tom delay
Iran contra connected cia director replaces rumsfeld
Iran contra figure back { December 3 2002 }
Iran contra men return power { August 20 2001 }
Irancontra figure to lead democracy efforts abroad { February 3 2005 }
James baker [jpg]
Karl rove strategist
Lieberman bush tip for un and war cabinet
Lieberman supports bush on iraq { September 25 2002 }
New attorney general okays torture { September 2007 }
New attorney general opposes habeas corpus { October 18 2007 }
New fed chairman will be different
New fed reserve pick noted for great depression work { October 24 2005 }
On social secrity lieberman is pure republican { March 7 2005 }
Paul wolfowitz [jpg]
Pentagon appoints irancontra figure for senior position { July 11 2005 }
Pentagon iraq policy architect feith leaving post
Pentagon meets expatriate iranian arms merchant { August 9 2003 }
Political groups paid wife and daughter of delay { April 6 2005 }
Powell three others resign from cabinet { November 15 2004 }
Powell under fire { April 24 2003 }
Powell veneman abraham and paige leaving cabinet { November 15 2004 }
Powerful karl rove { March 10 2003 }
Republican cpb chairman resigns
Republican critical of bolton caves in { May 12 2005 }
Return iran contra brigade { December 8 2002 }
Ridge resigns homeland security post
Roche army secretary northrop grumman { May 1 2003 }
Rove gets bigger role at white house
Rove identified link to fired US attorneys { March 12 2007 }
Rummy says we have known unknowns
Rumsfled asked to stay another term { December 3 2004 }
Russia lobby pays tom delay business trip { April 6 2005 }
Sec issues frist subpoena { October 13 2005 }
Second term bush team forced to be loyal { December 10 2004 }
Senator hagel ties to election machine company { January 29 2003 }
Snow new post shows whitehouse love for fox news { April 27 2006 }
Tenet defends CIA while going { July 9 2004 }
Tenet going
Tom delay airfare charged on lobbyist credit card { April 24 2005 }
Whitehouse shakeup rove role reduced { March 2006 }
Wolfowitz cabal

Files Listed: 86



Correction/submissions

CIA FOIA Archive

National Security
Archives
Support one-state solution for Israel and Palestine Tea Party bumper stickers JFK for Dummies, The Assassination made simple