News and Document archive source
copyrighted material disclaimer at bottom of page

NewsMinecabal-eliteunited-nations — Viewing Item


UN and US quarrel over iraq { November 14 2004 }

Original Source Link: (May no longer be active)
   http://www.nytimes.com/2004/11/14/international/14annan.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2004/11/14/international/14annan.html

November 14, 2004
DIPLOMACY
U.S. and U.N. Renew Quarrel Over Iraq
By WARREN HOGE

UNITED NATIONS, Nov. 12 - Secretary General Kofi Annan's reluctance to commit staff members to Iraq in large numbers and a series of comments he has made about the war have strained relations with the Bush administration and left many Americans bewildered, according to both supporters and critics of the United Nations.

Mr. Annan withdrew international staff members from Iraq in October 2003 in the wake of attacks on relief workers and the bombing of the United Nations' Baghdad headquarters, which killed 22 people, including the mission chief, Sergio Vieira de Mello. Although the United Nations has been assigned the task of setting up elections scheduled for January, Mr. Annan has declined to send more than a handful of electoral workers to Iraq, citing the lack of security forces to protect them.

"The Iraqis and the Americans are completely frustrated," said a senior American official at the United Nations, reporting views he said he heard in the White House this week. "The secretary general is still recommending many thousands of peacekeepers in Sierra Leone and the Congo, and yet there are seven election workers in Iraq. That tells the whole story."

This official said that warnings were resurfacing at the White House that the United Nations was risking becoming irrelevant and that such comments were now being combined with a dismissive attitude toward Mr. Annan himself.

"We're beyond anger," the official said. "We won re-election, Kofi's term is up in '06 and though we have been asking him to define the U.N. role in Iraq, he is thumbing his nose at us."

William H. Luers, president of the United Nations Association of the United States, acknowledged concern among the organization's backers. "I think a lot of Americans who are very sympathetic to the U.N. are confused with this last phase," he said.

"Most Americans don't really take into account the rule-of-law aspects of international behavior," Mr. Luers said. "We generally think what we do is right and in a certain sense we set the rules. Nonetheless, the world doesn't see it that way, and I think Kofi is talking to that world. I think he almost has to be where he is, but it's a tough time for him among Americans."

In an interview Thursday night at his office overlooking the East River, Mr. Annan said he was distressed by the criticism.

"I have tried to be as helpful as possible, and I have stated at every opportunity that the stabilization of Iraq is everyone's responsibility," Mr. Annan said. "I have argued that regardless of one's position on the war, we must all come together to stabilize Iraq."

At issue are three recent actions by Mr. Annan. In September, he suggested in a BBC interview that the war in Iraq was "illegal." He barred lawyers with the United Nations war crimes tribunal from taking part in training sessions last month for Iraqi judges and prosecutors who will be trying Saddam Hussein and other former Iraqi leaders. And two weeks ago he sent a letter to the United States, British and Iraqi governments warning that a military assault on Falluja could further alienate Iraqis and undermine the elections scheduled for January.

"All of these actions were unhelpful," said Rich Williamson, who was a deputy United States ambassador to the United Nations from 2001 to 2003. "Iraq is a place where the U.N. could show that it can make a valuable and important contribution, but it is just hurting itself in not helping the Iraqi people and sitting on the sidelines."

Further jeopardizing Mr. Annan's image in American eyes are the allegations of corruption and a cover-up in the scandal-ridden oil-for-food program and the intense anger on Capitol Hill at the refusal of the independent investigation headed by Paul A. Volcker, the former Federal Reserve chairman, to share documents with the various Congressional committees conducting their own inquiries.

Officials in Mr. Annan's office say they fear a return to the mood of the 1980's when the United States, the organization's single biggest donor, reacted to Congressional displeasure with the United Nations by withholding payments.

In the interview, Mr. Annan denied that he was being obstructionist over Iraq, and he contended that the United Nations had been instrumental in selecting the interim Iraqi government and had succeeded in training 6,000 election registrars and opening up hundreds of registration places across the country, despite a low number of United Nations staff members now in Baghdad.

Asked if he was under pressure from countries opposed to the war not to cooperate with the Americans, he replied: "Actually, it's the other way around. I am the one who is always telling governments, including those that did not support the war, that the civilization of Iraq is everyone's business because we cannot have a chaotic Iraq in the middle of that region."

He said he had had little success in persuading any countries to contribute troops to a 4,000-member force called for in a Security Council resolution in June that was intended to protect the United Nations and allow it to increase its presence in Iraq. Asked why countries were resisting, he said, "I think they are concerned about the security situation, and they probably have their own public opinion and parliaments to convince."

He said he was concerned about the damage to the United Nations' reputation caused by the oil-for-food scandal and accusations that he was being passive in reacting to it. But he said his interest in protecting the integrity of the Volcker investigation and his obligation to maintain its independence prevented him from taking any individual action.

As for the requests from Congressional committees for records and documents, he said, "It's a bit like having a case in court in New York, and you have several other courts from other places that want to deal with the same case."

Speaking of his directive preventing United Nations judicial officials from helping to create the Iraqi courts, he noted that there was no Security Council mandate for such assistance and cited the organization's formal opposition to judicial systems that include the death penalty. "As you know," he said, "quite a few members of this organization won't even extradite someone to a country where the death penalty exists."

With the United States pressuring him to increase the United Nations presence in Iraq and with the unions representing the world body's 60,000 employees around the globe demanding that the organization leave Iraq all together, Mr. Annan said he had to find creative ways to maintain a balance. "At least we are there, and many others are not there," he said.

"Without being boastful," he said, "I think that except for these activities of ours, we would not have moved as far as we have, whether it was the establishment of an interim Iraqi government or the preparation for the elections. I think our role has been essential, and not one that is played by an organization that is irrelevant."



Copyright 2004 The New York Times Company


iraq-oil-for-food
150 cases found united nations congo sex crimes { November 23 2004 }
Activists set to protest UN operation in haiti
Annan drafts gestapo changes for UN { March 20 2005 }
Annan farewell speech praises president truman
Annan prepares for privatisation of UN
Annan speaks against small arms
Bin laden rails united nations { November 3 2001 }
Bolton says UN must play critical role { April 11 2005 }
Britain organizes security members joint excercies { July 9 2004 }
Brzezinski global government
Bush talks bolster un role { August 21 2003 }
China and russia want stronger united nations { July 4 2005 }
Compromise grants more security council seats { December 2 2004 }
Confidential communication block un criticism { May 1 2003 }
Congress threatens withholding funds from UN without reforms { May 20 2005 }
Drew barrymore named friend of the un
Experts want united nations to fight global terrorism { November 29 2004 }
First peacekeeping training for give permanent security members { August 1 2004 }
Gestapo UN to stop education subversion
Group says UN doling out banned starlink foods
Groups debate un control of internet
Hateful words war crim in rwanda tribunal
Increase of slums and hoarding into cities
Iraq oil prove sized nearly 20 thousand files
John bolton says UN is led by US { March 8 2005 }
John bolton says UN is nothing without US { March 31 2005 }
Kosovo UN troops fuel sex trade { May 6 2004 }
Peacekeeper sex abuse in burundi
Peacekeepers congo sex scandal engulf un { December 23 2004 }
Peacekeepers underage sex in congo { December 18 2004 }
Plan for un to run internet { November 9 2003 }
Robot use will surge by 2007 says un report { October 21 2004 }
Russia to make billions for kyoto agreement { April 4 2006 }
Serb president blames UN for milosevic death
Shots fired at united nations { October 3 2002 }
Summit to focus on internet { December 5 2003 }
Talk of clinton to run UN { October 21 2004 }
Two united nation police killed in kosovo
UN 1987 delegate congressman funded alqaeda
UN and US quarrel over iraq { November 14 2004 }
UN chief opposes US troop withdrawal from iraq
UN chief plans visit iran and syria { August 24 2006 }
UN congo forces kill 50 congo militia
UN critizes bolivia revolts { June 15 2005 }
Un grab for internet control { December 2 2003 }
Un group seeks control of internet
UN hariri report praises lebanon faults syria { December 12 2005 }
UN helicopter crashes in sierra leone { June 29 2004 }
Un passes brit gestapo memo against incitement { September 15 2005 }
UN peacekeepers banned from sex in congolese { February 11 2005 }
UN peacekeepers may be punished in home country { March 25 2005 }
UN police proppring up kosovo sex trade { May 7 2004 }
UN resolution dodges iraqi sovereignty
UN signs pact with new world court opposed by US
UN troops accused in deaths of haitians
UN troops replace US troops in Haiti
UN troops traded gold for guns { May 23 2007 }
Un votes on tough terror measures { January 31 2004 }
UN wants NY cops for peacekeeping
UN warns west africa troops against sex abuse
UN wishes to register every child { February 23 2005 }
United nation is tool for pharmaceutical companies
United nations assaults radio for peace { November 4 2003 }
United nations battles bird flu
United nations blocks human cloning ban { November 6 2003 }
United nations condems cuba embargo
United nations guard makes swastikas for israel
United nations is tool of rich countries
United nations mandates EU forces in bosnia { November 20 2006 }
United nations surpresses iraq bomb report { March 4 2004 }
United Nations tired and convicted over iraq oil scandal { May 7 2004 }
United nations to untap 7 trillion for global causes { January 30 2006 }
United nations troops crack down in haiti { December 15 2004 }
United nations troops enforce liberia vote
United nations troops massacre haitians in slums { July 11 2005 }
United nations troops opened fire on haitian crowd
United states and united nations unite on iraq { December 30 2005 }
US drops effort for treaty banning cloning { November 20 2004 }
US threatens india to vote its way on UN
Us troops go under international control
US uses aid budget to bribe security council votes { December 17 2006 }
White house opposing cutting funds to united nations { June 16 2005 }
Whitehouse loans un billion renovation
WHO can restrict global travel and trade { May 23 2005 }
WHO sends deadly 1957 virus to thousands of labs
World health organization says less turkey bird flu cases { February 1 2006 }

Files Listed: 86



Correction/submissions

CIA FOIA Archive

National Security
Archives
Support one-state solution for Israel and Palestine Tea Party bumper stickers JFK for Dummies, The Assassination made simple