News and Document archive source
copyrighted material disclaimer at bottom of page

NewsMinecabal-elitecorporatewalmart — Viewing Item


Walmart pays ceo more and employees less than costco

Original Source Link: (May no longer be active)
   http://quote.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=10000039&refer=columnist_crystal&sid=arNjFjq0qpd0#

http://quote.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=10000039&refer=columnist_crystal&sid=arNjFjq0qpd0#

Graef Crystal is a columnist for Bloomberg News. The opinions expressed are his own.

Costco-Wal-Mart Pay -- Don't Discount Difference: Graef Crystal

Aug. 24 (Bloomberg) -- Costco Wholesale Corp. and Wal-Mart Stores Inc. both offer low-priced goods, yet when it comes to paying their employees, there is a difference in dollars and cents that starts with hourly workers and goes to the top.

Costco, the fourth-largest U.S. retailer, pays fulltime employees an average hourly wage of $17; Wal-Mart, the world's largest retailer, pays $9.68.

As for their CEOs, total 2004 pay for James Sinegal of the Issaquah, Washington-based Costco was $2.7 million; for H. Lee Scott of the Bentonville, Arkansas, Wal-Mart it was $17.9 million.

To provide a more solid basis of comparison with the pay of other companies, compensation in the remainder of this article centers, not on that 2004 figure but on average pay over three years. That's because at some companies long-term incentive grants are made every two or three years, not each year. Hence, three-year average pay is generally more representative than that for a single year.

Here is each CEO's three-year average pay for four different types of compensation. The three-year period for Costco ended Aug. 31, 2004; for Wal-Mart it ended Jan. 31, 2005.

(Total pay includes base salary; annual bonus; my estimate of the present value at grant of options granted during the three- year period based on the use of the Black-Scholes model; the value at grant of free-share awards made during the three-year period; payouts under other long-term incentive plans; and miscellaneous compensation. Pay data were obtained from Aon Consulting's eComp database.)

Three-Year Average Pay

Costco Wal-Mart
Form of Pay (000) (000)
Salary $350 $1,192
Bonus $67 $3,829
Other Pay ex Option PV* $25 $9,223
Option PV* $2,098 $8,485
Total Pay $2,540 $22,729
* Option Present Value

You would, of course, expect Wal-Mart to pay its CEO more than Costco, given the huge disparity in the size of the two companies. Wal-Mart's 2004 net sales were $285.2 billion, while those of Costco were $48.1 billion.

To calibrate for these differences, I compared the two CEOs with 500 other U.S. chief executives, all of whom ran companies with market caps of $3 billion or more as of April 2005. Multiple regression analysis was used to determine a ``going rate'' for each CEO for the 2002-2004 period, taking into account as many as three factors that were applicable to the particular form of compensation being studied: the size of the company, as measured by its 2004 net sales; the company's three-year weighted average total return; and the ratio of option present values to total pay. (The last-mentioned factor can be considered a proxy for the risk embedded in the CEO's pay package, given that options are generally the most risky form of executive pay.)

Compared With Others

Here's how the two CEOs came out compared with the 500 other U.S. CEOs:


Percent Above/ Percent Above/
Form of (Below) Market (Below) Market
Pay Costco Wal-Mart
Salary -73% -35%
Salary plus Bonus -90% -25%
Total ex Option PV -95% -4%
Total -89% 0%

Though Scott can't be considered overpaid given the huge size of his company, Sinegal, in contrast, is wildly underpaid.

A further example of the differences in pay culture between the two companies can be found in studying the stock option grants made to the two CEOs as a percentage of all option grants made during the three-year period to all employees.

Sinegal received an average of 1.88 percent of the total grants made to all employees, while Scott chewed up a much higher 4 percent.

And that difference is even larger than it looks, because Scott received a second-form of long-term incentive pay: free share grants worth an average of $8.7 million a year during the three-year period. Sinegal didn't receive any free-share grants.

So Costco pays its fulltime workers much more than Wal-Mart and its CEO much less than Wal-Mart -- but also much less than when Costco is compared with companies of similar size, performance and risk characteristics.

Sinegal's Performance

Now if money really motivates executive performance, you would expect to see Scott lapping the field over Sinegal in total returns to investors. Just the opposite has occurred.

Scott became CEO of Wal-Mart on Jan. 14, 2000. Measuring from Jan. 13, 2000, to the market close this Aug. 19, Wal-Mart's cumulative total return was negative 25.5 percent. That was considerably lower than the negative 8.2 percent cumulative return on the Standard & Poor's 500 Index for the same period.

As for Costco, its cumulative return was negative 5.4 percent, relatively more favorable than that of both Wal-Mart and the S&P 500.

Viewed over Sinegal's entire tenure, which stretches back to sometime in August 1988, and measuring from July 29, 1988, through the close on this Aug. 19, Costco's total return was 10.6 percent a year versus the 11.7 percent a year return on the S&P 500 Index.

The Scorecard

As for Wal-Mart, its total return during the same long period was a much higher 16 percent a year. That higher performance, however, was achieved solely when Scott's predecessor, David Glass, was in charge.

It is worth noting that in his last full year as CEO (the fiscal year ended Jan. 31, 1999), Glass's total pay was $9.1 million. That compares with Scott's average total pay for the three years ended Jan. 31, 2005, of $22.7 million a year.

So here's the scorecard during the overlapping tenure of the two CEOs. For Costco, the employees won. The shareholders also won in the sense that, during the period covered by Scott's tenure, Costco's total return, though negative, was better than that of the S&P 500 and much better than Wal-Mart's. But Sinegal lost. For Wal-Mart, the employees lost, the shareholders lost and Scott won.

If you're Scott, you like that outcome.

Last Updated: August 24, 2005 00:04 EDT


Activist takes million from walmart for mlk memorial { March 24 2006 }
Americans say walmart is bad for america
Canadian store near union contract will be closed by walmart
Class action sex discrimination lawsuit against walmart
Council sellsout black chicago community to walmart { April 21 2004 }
Ehrlich urged to return walmart money { May 4 2005 }
Empire of bargains remakes working world { November 23 2003 }
Executives knew walmart employees were illegals { November 8 2005 }
Foes dig in as walmart aims for new york city { February 10 2005 }
Germanys walmart goes for world conquest { April 26 2004 }
Gocery store windixie dies out to wal mart
Grocers treat employees like walmart employees
Grocery unions battle to stop invasion of giant stores { November 25 2003 }
Hacktivists piss off walmart
Heir john walton dies in plane crash
How costco became the anti walmart
India protests western style stores like walmart
La voters suburb reject wal mart supercenter
Legislature proposes special tax on walmart
Lobbyists hired by walmart to topped benefits bill { November 18 2005 }
Los angeles council hampers walmart plans
Los angeles fights walmart to protect jobs { April 2 2004 }
Los angeles voters send wal mart packing { April 7 2004 }
Maryland forces healthcare for walmart employees
Mexicans protest walmart near ruins
New pyramid mexican walmart threatens ancient treasures { November 5 2004 }
No walmart in chicago [jpg]
Pelosi says wal mart arrests terrorizing
Protesters bash wal mart attempts in two cities { May 2 2004 }
Scouring the globe to give shoppers 8d polo shirt { November 24 2003 }
Stymied by politicians walmart turns to losangeles voters { April 5 2004 }
Teens charged with bombing walmart in maine
Two walmart stores in quebec receive bomb threat { February 11 2005 }
Virginia town joins against walmart
Wal mart economic disease
Wal mart facing rising resistance { May 4 2004 }
Wal mart interested in acquisitions in brazil { August 25 2004 }
Wal mart invates mexico and mexico gladly surrenders { December 6 2003 }
Wal mart raids 300 illegal workers
Wal mart screws labor force { November 6 2003 }
Wal mart threat fuelds new urban politics { May 20 2004 }
Wal mart violated labor laws { January 13 2004 }
Wal marts benefits come under fire
Walmart bank threatens financial system says lawmakers
Walmart bank { January 7 2003 }
Walmart buys brazil supermarket chain
Walmart CEO goes offensive on critics
Walmart china inventory hits 18b this year
Walmart costs state taxpayers for workers { August 3 2004 }
Walmart customers overcharge problems { April 3 2004 }
Walmart cuts prices ahead of holidays to boost sales { November 21 2006 }
Walmart dependent on welfare for employees { November 7 2003 }
Walmart economy was keeping down inflation
Walmart forces jobs overseas
Walmart ge morgan banking system { May 23 2003 }
Walmart gets bigger
Walmart in offensive to boost image { September 8 2004 }
Walmart in queens scrapped due to protest
Walmart involved in congressional black caucus fundraiser { May 15 2005 }
Walmart locked janitors in stores
Walmart nation race to the bottom { February 18 2004 }
Walmart on fire [jpg]
Walmart operates intelligence spying network
Walmart pays ceo more and employees less than costco
Walmart recommends king for planet of the apes
Walmart reopens after arson fires { December 24 2004 }
Walmart threatens to double china outlets by 2006
Walmart to begin phased rfid tag
Walmart to use more partimers cheaper labor
Walmart uses extreme tactics to stop unions { May 2 2007 }
Walmart violates clean water act { May 12 2004 }
Walmart violates labor laws to stop unions { May 1 2007 }
Walmart wins warnings on future investigations { February 12 2005 }
Walmart
Walmarts wants stores throughout europe { May 24 2004 }
Winndixie cuts 326 to compete with walmart
Workers from indonesia nicaragua etc sue walmart
Zoning rules block kansas walmart supercenter

Files Listed: 78



Correction/submissions

CIA FOIA Archive

National Security
Archives
Support one-state solution for Israel and Palestine Tea Party bumper stickers JFK for Dummies, The Assassination made simple