News and Document archive source
copyrighted material disclaimer at bottom of page

NewsMine9-11wtc-collapse — Viewing Item


Wtc collapse inquiry rules out design flaw

Original Source Link: (May no longer be active)
   http://www.twincities.com/mld/twincities/news/nation/9962462.htm

http://www.twincities.com/mld/twincities/news/nation/9962462.htm

Posted on Wed, Oct. 20, 2004
WTC collapse inquiry rules out design flaw

Crashes fatally crippled support columns, investigators say

BY ERIC LIPTON

New York Times


WASHINGTON After the most sophisticated building analysis in U.S. history, federal investigators have largely ruled out a design flaw as a central factor in the collapse of the World Trade Center towers after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.

Since the twin towers fell in 2001, questions have reverberated among families of victims and fire-safety experts about whether insufficient fireproofing or an unusual weakness in the innovative, lightweight floors played a critical role in the collapse.

Instead, investigators tentatively conclude in documents released Tuesday, the towers failed because the structural columns at the buildings' core, damaged by the impact of the two airliners, buckled and shortened as the fires burned, gradually shifting more load to the towers' trademark exterior pinstripe columns. The exterior columns ultimately sustained such extraordinary stress and heat that they gave way.

The investigation based on an analysis of thousands of photographs and videos, an examination of nearly every element used to build the towers and computer-enhanced modeling of the plane impacts and spreading fires is not yet complete. A final report by the National Institute of Standards and Technology is expected in December or January.

In interviews Tuesday, the lead investigator and other engineers who have studied the collapse said the evidence increasingly suggested that the structures given the extreme conditions they faced, including temperatures that reached 900 or so degrees performed relatively well on the day of the attack.

"We always said we had no preconceived notions, and that we would look at the failure information dispassionately," said S. Shyam Sunder, lead investigator at the institute, a division of the Commerce Department, which conducted the two-year, $16 million inquiry at the request of Congress. "The buildings performed as they should have in the airplane impact and extreme fires to which they were subjected. There is nothing there that stands out as abnormal."

Elements of the design and construction of the towers, investigators said, certainly played a part in how long the buildings stood.

Buildings designed differently with more robustly protected and spread-out emergency stairwells, for example might still have resulted in fewer deaths, engineers said Tuesday.

For Leslie E. Robertson, the structural engineer who helped design the twin towers in the early 1960s, the latest findings buttress his assertion that the towers were fundamentally sound. His wife, Saw-Teen See, who is a managing partner at Robertson's New York design firm, said the report "validates the way we thought the structure would have performed."

But Sally Regenhard, who founded a group called the Skyscraper Safety Campaign in honor of her son, Christian Regenhard, a probationary firefighter who was one of 2,749 victims, said she was not ready to concede that the design were not fundamentally at fault.

The investigators have examined just about every possible factor that could have contributed to the collapse, including the steel used in the columns. Computer models were used to calculate, as accurately as possible, where different airplane parts traveled, and what kind of damage they did.

Then, intricate models were built, essentially recreating the resulting fires.

Through all this, particular attention has been focused on the innovative floors that were central to the design of the twin towers. The floors were particularly critical in the trade center because in office buildings built before the 1960s, structural columns and beams were generally spread throughout holding up the enormous weight and allowing the tower to resist the force from wind.

In the trade center, only the building's exterior and core had structural columns; between them were wide-open floors relatively lightweight, decklike structures. Some engineers have wondered if insufficient fireproofing on the floor trusses led them to fail, undermining the structural integrity of the towers.

The federal investigators found that the original fireproofing on the floors, as built, was sufficient to ensure that they met the New York City building code under standard testing parameters.

Instead, the reports released Tuesday say, the Boeing 767 planes ripped through a swath of exterior steel columns, resulting in an immediate redistribution of the load to adjacent perimeter columns and, to a lesser extent, to the core columns.

As the planes penetrated the towers, they destroyed sections of the floors, knocked off spray-on fireproofing and severed three to 10 of the core columns in each tower.

The report found that the towers were able to stand, despite the initial assault, as "loads on the damaged columns were redistributed to other intact core and perimeter columns mostly via the floor systems and to a lesser extent, via the hat truss," a steel structure at the top of the towers that was connected to the core and perimeter columns.

The infernos that erupted in the two towers are to blame for the ultimate collapse, the reports found.

As temperatures rose in the buildings, the remaining core columns softened and buckled, shifting much of the burden to the building's exterior. The floors, which largely remained intact outside the impact zone, reacted by pulling the exterior columns inward, adding to the extreme stress on the exterior columns.

In the north tower, the exterior columns gradually started to bow inward and then buckle. Ultimately, the entire upper section of the building above the impact zone tilted to the south, sealing the fate of the tower.

The floors played a more significant role in the collapse sequence in the south tower, the investigators said. Fires there caused them to sag by as much as 2 feet, adding to the inward pulling that already had started because of the buckling of the core columns.

But the investigators say that if a typical office fire had occurred without the plane impact "it is likely that burnout would have occurred without collapse."




051205explosives [wmv]
270404northtower [jpg]
270404southtower [jpg]
2750 degree fire melts bridge steel beams { April 30 2007 }
7 wtc collapse { November 29 2001 }
Ailing wtc rescue workers sue 1b insurance fund { July 18 2007 }
Body searched halted for gold search at wtc { March 9 2007 }
Bush insider said collapse was controlled demolishion
Bush says ksm planted explosives in a building
Comparing twin towers { October 23 2002 }
Debate over wtc fires draws experts { November 15 2004 }
Dislodged fireproofing key to wtc collapse
Engineering report released in trade center collapse
Engineers built wtc to withstand boeing jet { February 27 1993 }
Fire engineers challenge fed theory { May 27 2002 }
Fire wasnt hot enough to bring down towers says study { April 6 2005 }
Firefighters call giuliani 911 perfomance a disgrace
Fireproofing dismissed as wtc collapse cause { October 19 2004 }
First struck seconds to fall { February 24 2002 }
Giuliani accused on streets of allowing wtc deaths { May 29 2007 }
Giulliani caused firefighter deaths on 911 { January 22 2008 }
Giulliani promoted those who ran before towers fell
Graphic look { October 29 2002 }
Human remains search could move off site
Madrid building fire ap [jpg]
Madrid skyscraper burns 24 hours without collapse
Madrid windsor tower burns but no collapse { February 14 2005 }
Medical examiner says lung death from wtc debris { May 24 2007 }
Nist response to wtc controlled demolition accusations
Nist still cant figure out why wtc7 fell { June 2007 }
NY firefighters face questions on collapse { November 14 2003 }
Over 750 bone fragments found on deutsche bank building { October 26 2006 }
Planes hit tower weakest spot { September 12 2001 }
Report on trade center collapse emphasize fireproofing { April 5 2005 }
Search for human remains at wtc grows { October 27 2006 }
Silverstein pull wtc building 7 [mp3]
Stephen jones attacked on msnbc
Study faults bolts
Study suggests design flaws didnt doom towers { October 20 2004 }
Topple [jpg]
Towers fell almost free fall { April 30 2002 }
Why world trade center collapsed
Woman_in_blackhole [jpg]
Woman_wtc [jpg]
Wtc collapse evidence
Wtc collapse inquiry rules out design flaw
Wtc collapse secret { September 30 2002 }
Wtc huge pile driver { September 13 2001 }
Wtc officials recover more human remains { October 24 2006 }
Wtc pull building 6 [mp3]
Wtc structure built to withstand jet crash { February 27 1993 }

Files Listed: 51



Correction/submissions

CIA FOIA Archive

National Security
Archives
Support one-state solution for Israel and Palestine Tea Party bumper stickers JFK for Dummies, The Assassination made simple