News and Document archive source
copyrighted material disclaimer at bottom of page

NewsMine9-11 — Viewing Item


Government denies access to 911 tapes and transcripts { February 9 2005 }

Original Source Link: (May no longer be active)
   http://www.newsday.com/news/local/newyork/nyc-wtc0210,0,4228797.story?coll=ny-nynews-headlines

http://www.newsday.com/news/local/newyork/nyc-wtc0210,0,4228797.story?coll=ny-nynews-headlines

Court to decide access to 9/11 tapes

BY GRAHAM RAYMAN
STAFF WRITER

February 9, 2005, 7:03 PM EST

ALBANY -- The state's highest court heard arguments Wednesday in a two-year struggle over access to a trove of city transcripts and tape recordings from Sept. 11, 2001.

At issue before the Court of Appeals is access to tapes of 911 calls, Fire Department dispatches and transcripts of interviews with hundreds of firefighters who responded on the day of the attack.

The New York Times filed the lawsuit after the city declined to release the items. The paper was later joined by relatives of civilians and firefighters who died at the World Trade Center.

In fighting the suit the city has cited privacy issues, concern over the emotions of the grieving and the ongoing terror prosecution of Zacarias Moussaoui in Virginia.

In arguments yesterday before the seven-member panel, the case appeared to be destined to become a pivotal test of the effectiveness of the Freedom of Information Law.

Judge Albert Rosenblatt pressed the plaintiff to "give us an example of a privacy interest. Otherwise there is no standard."

"The burden of proof is on the city," Norman Siegel, a lawyer representing the families, said, adding that the city did not consult "a single family member" before refusing to release the items.

John Hogrogian, a lawyer for the city, did not deny that.

"I actually asked about that and the answer was it was apparent," Hogrogian said.

He suggested at one point that the request was "ghoulish."

About two dozen relatives of Sept. 11 victims journeyed to Albany to attend the hearing.

"If the city has someone who was against releasing the tapes we should have heard from them," said Russell Mercer, the stepfather of firefighter Scott Kopytko, 33, who died on Sept. 11.

When one judge asked what the Fire Department was most concerned about, Hogrogian said, "Opinions and recommendations addressed to Fire Department practices and things that did not work that day or were not implemented."

"How does criticism fit in?" Judge Victoria Graffeo asked.

"I believe that would have been an opinion," he said.

"That's a rather dangerous way to describe an opinion," Graffeo replied. There was no decision issued yesterday.

Toward the end of the hearing one judge indicated any ruling would likely be sent back to the lower court to be implemented.
Copyright © 2005, Newsday, Inc.



binladen
doubts-official-story
epa-air-quality
flight-schools
flight11-aa-wtc
flight77-aa-pentagon
flight93-ua
forewarned
inquiry
insurance-scam
investigation-pre911
lawsuits
norad-faa-response
not-focused-on-terror
pakistan
questions
saudis
suspects
sympathy-for-attacks
taliban
wtc-collapse
105 terrorists visas
9 11 commision { May 23 2003 }
9 11 terror attack binladen
911 flight controller handled egypt air flight 990
911 gas theory
911 suspect related wtc93 plotter { June 5 2002 }
911 widow ellen mariani letter to bush { December 1 2003 }
Air traffic controllers recall events { September 11 2002 }
Bush attends 911 memorial then fundraiser
Bush reaction { December 4 2001 }
Car bomb explodes outside state department on september 11
Cheney recalls taking charge from bunker { September 11 2001 }
Congress to investigating 911 loan abuses { September 9 2005 }
Day of the attack
Debunking conspiracy theorists
Deception
Evidence shows 911 attacks were delayed
Fbi grabs ap fedex document { May 8 2003 }
Fbi john oneill gets his own mini series { May 2 2005 }
Federal protective services deny car bomb occured
From the cockpits
Goss refuses to discipline cia officials for 911 lapse { October 5 2005 }
Government denies access to 911 tapes and transcripts { February 9 2005 }
Investigating the hijackings { July 23 2004 }
John oneill { September 12 2001 }
Man claims living wife died on 911 { February 5 2004 }
Nearly half newyork dead not identified
Need new pearl harbor { September 11 2001 }
New 911 cia report finds fault with cia officials { August 26 2005 }
Non arabic { September 19 2002 }
Number of rny dead 2000 less tally { October 26 2001 }
Ny fd releases 911 oral histories transmissions { August 12 2005 }
Palestinians candy
Pilots of hijacked flights on 911
Port authority releases 911 transcipts { August 29 2003 }
Pre attack { September 26 2001 }
Rare tape of wtc attacks surfaces
Reichstag fire { September 13 2002 }
Six years later bush consistently cites 911
Sora friedman
Sound recorded { August 7 2002 }
Springsteen sings { July 30 2002 }
Tumbling woman art [jpg]
Tumbling woman art { September 18 2002 }
Two white suspects in bin laden probe
Wash post offers free ads for 911 pentagon event { August 16 2005 }
Wtc_devil [jpg]

Files Listed: 47



Correction/submissions

CIA FOIA Archive

National Security
Archives
Support one-state solution for Israel and Palestine Tea Party bumper stickers JFK for Dummies, The Assassination made simple