News and Document archive source
copyrighted material disclaimer at bottom of page

NewsMine9-11binladenafter-death-in-dec-2001 — Viewing Item

New fake bin laden tape has fake beard

Original Source Link: (May no longer be active)

U.S.: No Overt Threats In Osama Video
WASHINGTON, Sept. 7, 2007(CBS/AP) A new videotape purported to be from Osama bin Laden, nearly 30 minutes long, contains no overt threat against the United States, a U.S. security official tells CBS News.

Intelligence analysts are still looking at the video image to determine if the speaker is bin Laden, the official said.

However, according to the U.S. official, a transcript of the tape reveals the following:

# The speaker who appears to be bin Laden makes specific references to the U.S. involvement in the Iraq War, which indicates the tape may have been made sometime in 2007.

# The speaker talks about the politics of a U.S. withdrawal, an issue that was not current at the time of bin Laden's last confirmed video in 2004.

# The speaker seems to criticize Democrats and their lack of action in pulling U.S. troops out of Iraq. He reportedly makes references to Democrats' campaign promises to start a withdrawal and notes the failure to follow up.

Officials will not say how the government obtained the tape, but it may have been briefly posted this morning on a Jihadist Web site, reports CBS News correspondent Bob Orr. That Web site since has crashed.

U.S. officials said they do not know when, or if, al Qaeda will release the tape. The officials brushed aside questions about whether the U.S. would preemptively put it out.

Al Qaeda's media arm had previously announced a new bin Laden video would be released ahead of the sixth anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks. The video, if authentic, would be the first video from the terror chief in nearly three years.

Earlier Thursday, the White House said that any new video from bin Laden would serve to highlight threats the West faces. Analysts noted that al Qaeda tends to mark the Sept. 11 anniversary with a slew of messages, and Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff told CBS News Friday afternoon there is no credible, imminent threat against the U.S.

Intelligence analysts will also be looking for any sign that the message indicates attacks to come, reports Orr.

Still, if the man in the video is bin Laden, his appearance would be significant. The al Qaeda leader has not appeared in new video footage since October 2004, and he has not put out a new audiotape in more than a year, his longest period without a message.

One difference in his appearance was immediately obvious. The announcement had a still photo from the coming video, showing bin Laden addressing the camera, his beard fully black. In his past videos, bin Laden's beard was almost entirely gray with dark streaks.

Bin Laden's beard appears to have been dyed, a popular practice among Arab leaders, said Rita Katz, director of the SITE Institute, a Washington-based group that monitors terror messages.

"I think it works for their (al Qaeda's) benefit that he looks young, he looks healthy," Katz said.

CBS News consultant Jere Van Dyk scoffs at that.

"I have never in all my years here ever seen a man dye his hair black," he wrote in e-mail from Afghanistan. "Men here do not dye their beards black."

Van Dyk asked Abdul Salem Zaeef, a former Taliban spokesman, deputy defense minister, and ambassador, about the change in bin Laden's appearance.

"He listened carefully, smiled and said the picture is an old one," writes Van Dyk.
The announcement that a video would be released and the photo appeared in a banner advertisement on an Islamic militant Web site where al Qaeda's media arm, Al-Sahab, frequently posts messages.

"Soon, God willing, a videotape from the lion sheik Osama bin Laden, God preserve him," the advertisement read, signed by Al-Sahab. Such announcements are usually put out one to three days before the video is posted on the Web.

"Why this new video?" asks Van Dyk. "To recruit, to show that he is alive, to mark the anniversary of 9/11, maybe to send a message, not just to the west, to the Umma, the worldwide Muslim community, but to (Pakistan's President Gen. Pervez) Musharraf."

The anniversary has always been a major media event for al Qaeda - a chance for it to drum up support among extremists, tout itself as the leading militant group and show off its continued survival.

"They've always gone out of their way to commemorate it," said Ben Venzke, chief executive officer of IntelCenter, which is based in Alexandria, Virginia. "Historically the anniversary of 9/11 has never been drawn to attacks. It's drawn to video releases."

But the fact that bin Laden is delivering the message is significant, he said. Whether the message will indicate a potential attack will depend on what bin Laden says.

President Bush used a Sydney speech to list dead and captured terrorists, reports CBS News White House correspondent Peter Maer.

"The fight against terrorists in this region is one of the untold success stories in the region," Mr. Bush said.

But left unstated was the obvious: bin Laden remains at large.

Bin Laden "is most likely hiding among Pashtuns as they are the people that inhabit both sides of the Afghan-Pakistani border; or, he is being protected by some institution," says Van Dyk. "He is somewhere, most probably, in western Pakistan."

The White House said that any new video message from bin Laden would only underscore the threat the United States and other nations face from extremists.

"Six years after 9/11, the arrests in Germany and Denmark this week and the battles we fight against al Qaeda in Iraq, Afghanistan, southeast Asia and around the world remind us of the continuing threat we face from extremists and why we must continue to take the fight to them wherever they are," said Gordon Johndroe, a spokesman for the National Security Council at the White House.

It's the first images of bin Laden since an Oct. 29, 2004 videotape, just before the U.S. presidential elections. In that appearance three years ago, he said America could avoid another 9/11 style attack if it stopped threatening Muslims.

The new video also end the longest period bin Laden has gone without releasing a message. His last audiotape was on July 1, 2006, in which he welcomed new leader of al Qaeda in Iraq succeeding the slain Abu Musab al-Zarqawi.

Bin Laden went silent for a similar long stretch before - from Dec. 28, 2004 to Jan. 19, 2006. That absence sparked widespread speculation he was ill, wounded or possibly dead.

There has been little such speculation since then. U.S. officials have repeatedly said over the past year they believe the al Qaeda leader is alive. He is thought to be hiding in the tribal regions of western Pakistan near the border with Afghanistan.

During bin Laden's silence, his deputy Egyptian-born Ayman al-Zawahri has been frequently issuing videos and audiotapes.

Al-Zawahri appeared in a 2006 video marking the 9/11 anniversary. An anniversary video in 2003 showed footage of bin Laden and al-Zawahri walking through mountain paths, with voice-over messages from both leaders.

MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

5 years later binladen trail stone cold { September 10 2006 }
Albright thinks bush is hiding binladen { December 17 2003 }
Alive in pakistan
Alleged dec 2004 tape criticizes saudis
Aug02 attacks
Bin laden asked zarqawi to attack on american soil { March 1 2005 }
Bin laden asks US to fund hamas { March 2006 }
Bin laden calls war crusader zionist alliance
Bin laden compares barbaric US with saddam
Bin laden escaped
Bin laden nukes [gif]
Bin laden refers to unaccurate 19 hijackers number
Bin laden says US plans crusade in somalia
Bin laden tape a fake { November 29 2002 }
Bin laden tape authentic says cia
Bin laden trail is completely cold { December 5 2004 }
Bin laden vows never to be captured alive { January 2006 }
Bin laden works with taliban says uk tv { February 2007 }
Binladen audio tape for europeans { October 2007 }
Binladen demands zarqawi body returned to jordan
Binladen funded bali
Binladen illness is rumor by taliban enemies says spokesman { June 16 2005 }
Binladen is organizing attack on US for summer 04 { July 9 2004 }
Binladen offers gold for killing US officials { May 6 2004 }
Binladen suicide trojan threatens web { July 24 2004 }
Binladen surrounded by special forces { February 22 2004 }
Binladen threatens political assasination while dead
Binladen triggers morocco bombings { May 18 2003 }
Binladen voice tape april 03
Binlanden back
Bl alive more attacks
Bl email bbc { March 28 2002 }
Bl emails { March 28 2002 }
Bounty for binladen doubled from 25m to 50m
British search yemen
Bro confirms tapes
Bush says oct tape proves war goes on { October 19 2003 }
Cant find binladen
Cia confused on bin laden dying claims { May 2008 }
Cia disbands bin laden unit { July 4 2006 }
Cia not hunting for binladen
Cia says bin laden will be caught { July 23 2004 }
Cia says iraq tape probably bin laden
Cia says saddam capture tape from dead binladen { January 6 2004 }
Cia thinks bl runs al qaeda
Cia thinks tape binladen { April 11 2003 }
Democrats warn terror { November 15 2002 }
Documents say bin laden escaped US grasp { November 2001 }
Elite unites hunt { September 3 2002 }
Escaped { January 15 2002 }
Faked satellite to escape { January 21 2003 }
Fled to tora bora
French say bin laden dies august of 2006 { September 24 2006 }
Hails anti west attacks { October 14 2002 }
High tech hunt for binladen 24 hours day
Hunting for binladen
In good health
Intelligence narrowing binladens whereabouts
Intercepted paper note
Islamic web site stirs confusion about bin laden death { April 29 2005 }
Laden arrest claims false says pentagon { February 29 2004 }
Linked to bali { October 20 2002 }
Made stocks fall
May 2005 pakistan foreign minister said binladen alive { September 11 2001 }
Musharraf almost caught binladen he says
New bin laden tape like political leader
New bin laden tape supports pakestinians { May 16 2008 }
New fake bin laden tape has fake beard
New fake bin laden tape praises noam chomsky
New urgency binladen hunt { March 11 2003 }
New videos
No air pretend video
No fake bin laden messages for 10 months
Now thought alive { November 14 2002 }
Nytimes mystery { September 30 2002 }
Obama says osama should be brought to trial { June 18 2008 }
Oct 2003 new audio tape { October 19 2003 }
Officials frustrated in 911 hunt { July 12 2007 }
On border
Osama tape rips saddam after capture
Pakistan denies bin laden deal
Pakistan denies progress osama hunt
Pakistani troops pull back from binladen hunt { December 5 2004 }
Praises bali attack { October 14 2002 }
Purported bin laden iraq tape blames companies
Reward for binladen doubles { March 19 2004 }
Search for binladen intensifies
Search for binladen { March 7 2003 }
Spy satellite call { October 6 2002 }
Swiss binladen tape faked { November 29 2002 }
Taliban chief hasnt seen bin laden since 2001
Tape to come
Top deputy tape
Uk italy reject purported binladen truce
Urges suicide attacks { February 11 2003 }
Voice threats { October 6 2002 }
Weak attempt in bin laden hunt

Files Listed: 97


CIA FOIA Archive

National Security
Support one-state solution for Israel and Palestine Tea Party bumper stickers JFK for Dummies, The Assassination made simple